Introduction
The roofing industry is booming and merely having a website isn’t sufficient. Competition has also changed drastically from word of mouth driving business for most roofers to new technologically savvy roofers with marketing experts picking off the competition. In such as fast paced industry, the real challenge lies in ensuring that your website stands out amidst a sea of competitors who are likely all pushing dollars into roofing SEO services. Search engine optimization, or SEO, is no longer just a buzzword but a critical component of a successful roofing business strategy. SEO competitive analysis, a main category under the SEO umbrella, is a powerful tool that helps roofing companies understand who they’re up against and how to outperform them and dominate.
SEO competitive analysis allows you to gain a deeper understanding of your rivals’ strengths and weaknesses through understanding their search queries and what is driving most of their traffic. By examining their strategies, you can dive deeper to uncover valuable insights to craft a more effective SEO strategy going forward.
This guide explores the steps and tools needed for a thorough competitive analysis, helping your roofing business thrive in the new digital landscape.
What Is SEO Competitive Analysis for Roofing Companies?
SEO competitive analysis is the process of evaluating your competitors’ search engine performance to improve and influence your own tactics and strategies. For roofing companies, this means more than just ranking nationally; it’s about dominating local searches like “roof repair near me” or “emergency roofing [city].” Understanding where your competitors stand helps you identify opportunities to outperform them.
Analyzing the competition uncovers insights that shape a smarter, more targeted SEO strategy. This involves examining various elements of your competitors’ online presence, from their keyword strategies to their backlink profiles.
How to Identify Your Roofing SEO Competitors
Identifying your SEO competitors is a crucial first step in competitive analysis. Grasping both local and online competitors is key to an effective SEO strategy. The competition landscape has shifted, blurring the lines between online and offline competitors, making it necessary to consider various types of competitors.
For roofers, it is important to consider both local competitors and those with a strong online presence. Of course, local competitors might be more familiar and relevant, but we have seen strong local competitors breakout to new markets and expand their footprint in some cases even across state lines. We’ll break down different types of competitors and how to identify them, setting the stage for a comprehensive competitive analysis.
📈 Check out our Roofing SEO Overview to plan your next moves.
Local Competitors vs. Online Competitors
Local competitors are roofing companies physically located near your business. While they may have a strong reputation in the community, they often lack an effective digital marketing strategy—making them less visible in search engine results. In many markets, only a handful of local roofers dominate online visibility by investing in SEO and targeted marketing tactics. These are the competitors you’ll want to watch closely and aim to outperform.
Online competitors, on the other hand, are businesses or directories that outrank you for your target keywords—regardless of their physical proximity. For roofers, these can include larger regional companies that operate in your area, or even suppliers and manufacturers whose optimized content pushes their affiliated contractors higher in search results.
Understanding the distinction between local and online competition is essential. Local competitors may have strong community ties, but online competitors are often the ones capturing search traffic and potential leads through superior SEO strategies.
By analyzing both types, you can position your roofing business to compete effectively in both the physical market and digital landscape.
Using Tools to Find Competitors
Tools like SEMrush, Ahrefs, and BrightLocal make it easier than ever to identify which competitors are outranking your roofing business—and for which keywords. These platforms offer in-depth insights into keyword performance, backlink profiles, and overall online visibility. Even simple, manual Google searches using localized keywords can help reveal who’s actually showing up in your service area.
If you don’t have access to these tools, hiring an experienced SEO professional is a smart move. Not only do they bring the right tools to the table, but they also have the expertise to interpret the data, identify opportunities, and develop a strategy that drives real results.
With the right approach, these tools can help you create a detailed competitive analysis report—pinpointing both direct local rivals and indirect online competitors—so you can position your business more effectively in search.
Spotting Indirect Competitors
In many local markets, national franchises, review sites, and directories compete for the same search visibility as roofing contractors—even if they don’t actually offer roofing services. These indirect competitors can pull valuable traffic away from your business simply by dominating the top positions in local search results.
Indirect competition isn’t limited to other service providers. Platforms like Yelp, Angi, and HomeAdvisor often attract potential customers who are searching for roofers, redirecting attention before users ever see your website. Even though these platforms aren’t your direct competitors, their presence in search results makes them powerful players in your digital space.
By studying how these platforms rank—whether through backlinks, local SEO tactics, or content structure—you can uncover opportunities to strengthen your own online presence and reclaim visibility in your service area.
Key SEO Metrics to Analyze Your Competitors
Understanding core SEO metrics is essential for evaluating your competitors and crafting a winning digital strategy. These insights help you identify where competitors are outperforming you—and where they’re falling short. But it’s important to remember: there’s no magic switch or single tactic that will instantly boost your rankings. SEO success comes from a consistent, multi-pronged strategy tailored to your specific market and goals.
The following are some of the most critical areas to assess during a competitor analysis:
-
Domain Authority – Gauges overall site credibility and trustworthiness in search engines.
-
Backlink Profiles – Reveals the quality and quantity of inbound links that boost rankings.
-
Organic Traffic – Indicates how much search-driven visibility your competitors are capturing.
-
Top-Performing Keywords – Highlights which search terms are driving the most traffic.
-
On-Page Optimization Techniques – Includes title tags, meta descriptions, keyword usage, and more.
-
Content Strategy – Evaluates how competitors structure and optimize their content to attract visitors.
-
Local SEO Signals – Covers Google Business Profile optimization, citations, local links, and reviews.
-
Technical SEO – Looks at site speed, mobile usability, indexing, and other backend factors.
Each of these metrics offers valuable insight into how your competitors are succeeding—and where you have opportunities to outperform them. A thorough, ongoing analysis of these areas will help guide your long-term SEO strategy and position your roofing business for sustainable growth online.
Domain Authority and Backlink Profile
A high domain authority signals that a website is trusted by search engines—making it more likely to rank higher in search results. One of the key drivers of domain authority is a strong backlink profile. When competitors earn backlinks from reputable, high-authority websites, it boosts their credibility and search visibility.
Roofing companies with a large number of high-quality backlinks often enjoy a competitive edge in search rankings. That’s why analyzing your competitors’ backlink strategies is so important.
By studying where their backlinks come from, you can uncover valuable link-building opportunities for your own site. Targeting similar sources—such as industry publications, local directories, or trusted home improvement blogs—can help strengthen your own backlink profile and close the SEO gap.
This strategic approach not only improves your rankings over time but also builds long-term trust with search engines.
Organic Traffic and Top-Performing Keywords
Analyzing the top-ranking pages of your competitors offers a wealth of insight into what’s driving their search performance. You can uncover:
-
-
The topics and keywords that are bringing in the most traffic
-
Estimated traffic volumes, providing a snapshot of their visibility
-
High-performing keywords, which signal what’s working in their SEO strategy
-
While reviewing this data can be time-consuming, the payoff is significant. Understanding which keywords are fueling your competitors’ success allows you to benchmark your own SEO performance and fine-tune your keyword strategy accordingly.
By identifying the search terms that matter most in your industry, you can optimize your content to target similar queries, close performance gaps, and attract more qualified traffic to your site. This competitive keyword analysis is a key step toward improving rankings and gaining an edge in local search.
On-Page Optimization Techniques
Effective on-page optimization is a cornerstone of high-ranking content. By examining key on-page elements on your competitors’ websites, you can uncover how well their pages are optimized—and where you have room to improve.
Key elements to review include:
-
-
Page Titles – Should be clear, keyword-rich, and compelling
-
H1 Headings – Indicate the main topic and help structure content
-
Meta Descriptions – Influence click-through rates by summarizing the page’s value
-
Keyword Placement – Reveals how strategically competitors use target keywords within content
-
Competitors that rank well typically use these elements to improve both user experience and search visibility. Analyzing their on-page SEO strategies helps you identify best practices, avoid common pitfalls, and refine your own optimization approach.
By applying these insights, you can enhance your website’s structure, relevance, and overall performance in search engine results—giving you a competitive edge in your local market.
Content Strategy
Content remains one of the most powerful tools for improving search rankings—especially when it’s tailored to local roofing needs. By analyzing your competitors’ content, you can gain valuable insights into what’s working and how to elevate your own strategy.
Key factors to assess include:
-
-
Blog publishing frequency – Indicates how consistently they’re producing new content
-
Topic depth and relevance – Reveals how well they address specific roofing questions
-
Word count – Can suggest how comprehensive and competitive their content is
-
Engagement metrics – Such as comments, shares, or backlinks, to gauge user interest
-
Competitors often use a variety of formats—how-to guides, service area content, FAQs, or videos—to reach and engage their audience. Observing these trends helps you identify content gaps in your own strategy and spot opportunities to create more targeted, valuable content.
Understanding which topics and formats resonate with potential customers allows you to craft a content plan that not only attracts more traffic but also improves your rankings in the search engine results pages (SERPs).
Local SEO Signals
When it comes to dominating the local pack in Google search results, strong local SEO signals make all the difference. Key elements to watch include:
-
-
Google Business Profiles – Fully optimized profiles with photos, service areas, and updates perform better
-
NAP Consistency – Ensures your business name, address, and phone number are uniform across all listings
-
Customer Reviews – Quantity, quality, and response rate all influence your local rankings
-
Competitors with more positive reviews and accurate, consistent citations are often favored by Google’s algorithm—boosting their visibility in local search.
By monitoring these local SEO signals, you can gain insight into how competitors are positioning themselves in the local market. Studying their strategies reveals best practices and highlights opportunities to improve your own presence—whether that’s refining your Google Business Profile, building more citations, or encouraging more 5-star reviews.
Improving these local ranking factors can significantly increase your visibility in local search results and help attract more qualified, local customers to your roofing business.
Technical SEO
Behind every top-ranking website is solid technical SEO. Elements like fast site speed, mobile responsiveness, clean URLs, and proper schema markup are not just best practices—they’re essential for both rankings and user experience.
Many roofing websites lose visibility due to technical missteps, such as slow load times or poor mobile optimization. This presents a clear opportunity for you to outperform them by ensuring your own site is technically sound.
By analyzing your competitors’ technical SEO, you can uncover:
-
-
Common performance issues they’ve resolved (or failed to fix)
-
How their website structure supports crawlability and indexing
-
The use of structured data to enhance visibility in search results
-
Reviewing these aspects can highlight both gaps in your own site and best practices you may not yet be implementing. Strengthening your technical SEO not only improves your position in search engine rankings—it also enhances usability, which keeps visitors on your site longer and encourages conversions.
Uncovering Content Gaps and Keyword Opportunities
One of the most effective ways to enhance your SEO strategy is by identifying content gaps—topics or keywords your competitors rank for that your site doesn’t currently address. Using tools can help you find keyword gaps enabling you to pinpoint opportunities and create optimized content to fill them.
This process helps you:
-
Discover missing keywords and high-performing topics
-
Understand where competitors are gaining traffic you’re not
-
Develop content that aligns with what your target audience is actively searching for
By producing high-quality content around these gaps, you can attract additional search traffic, generate more leads, and stay competitive in your local market.
More importantly, gap-focused content ensures you’re consistently delivering relevant, valuable information that meets your audience’s needs—while also reinforcing your brand’s voice and authority. This strategic approach keeps your content fresh, competitive, and aligned with your long-term SEO goals.
Backlink Gap Analysis: Stealing the SEO Juice
Competitors often rank higher because they’ve earned strong backlinks from directories, industry blogs, manufacturers, and local partners. To close the gap, focus on how to replicate competitor links and build net-new authority:
-
Audit referring domains to identify the specific directories, manufacturers, and local partners sending them authority.
-
Run targeted outreach to secure features, quotes, and resource-page placements.
-
Build and standardize citations to match—and eventually exceed—their footprint.
A focused backlink gap analysis surfaces high-value prospects your rivals already leverage. Pursuing these placements strengthens your backlink profile, boosts authority, and improves rankings—letting you capitalize on competitor momentum while building a more resilient online presence.
Common Roofing SEO Pitfalls (and How to Avoid Them)
Many roofing sites still lean on keyword stuffing and duplicate content, which hurts relevance and trust. Others ignore mobile performance/Core Web Vitals, dragging down local rankings. Missing schema markup, inaccurate NAP data, and poor UX (weak CTAs, cluttered layouts, slow pages) are additional weak spots you can exploit.
Avoid these traps by prioritizing natural language and unique content, mobile-first speed, LocalBusiness/Service schema, consistent NAP across citations, and clean, conversion-focused UX.
Identifying competitors’ mistakes helps you sidestep them, tighten your strategy, and deliver a better user experience—leading to stronger rankings and more qualified leads.
Turning Analysis Into Action: Building Your SEO Strategy
Use competitive insights to update your keyword map, upgrade content, and close technical gaps. Prioritize quick wins first—fix broken links, optimize titles/meta on key service pages, and improve internal linking.
-
Refresh keyword strategy: map primary/secondary terms to pages and target gap keywords.
-
Improve content: expand thin pages, add local examples/FAQs, sharpen CTAs.
-
Tighten technicals: boost Core Web Vitals, ensure mobile-first UX, add schema, fix crawl/index issues.
-
Leverage off-page wins: replicate high-value backlinks and citations revealed in your analysis.
-
Plan + measure: set milestones, owners, and KPIs (rankings, CTR, leads), then iterate in sprints.
Make competitor analysis a recurring cadence, not a one-off. Continuous optimization compounds gains and sustains long-term search performance.
Insights. Ideas. In Your Inbox
Summary
SEO competitive analysis is essential for roofing companies that want to dominate local search. By pinpointing competitors, tracking key metrics, and uncovering content and backlink opportunities, you can build a robust strategy that consistently outperforms the market. Revisit your analysis on a regular cadence as algorithms, competitors, and customer behavior evolve, and turn findings into a roadmap you can execute quarter by quarter.
Aim beyond parity. Don’t just match rivals—surpass them by delivering greater value through helpful content, superior UX, and trustworthy local signals. Stay vigilant, iterate often, and drive sustainable visibility, qualified leads, and long-term growth in an ever-changing digital landscape.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is SEO competitive analysis?
SEO competitive analysis is essential for assessing your competitors’ search engine performance, allowing you to identify their strengths and weaknesses. This evaluation enables you to develop a more effective and targeted SEO strategy for your own business.
Why is local SEO important for roofing companies?
Local SEO is essential for roofing companies as it enhances visibility in local searches, making it easier for potential customers in your area to find your services. By optimizing for local queries, you increase your chances of attracting more business.
How can I identify my SEO competitors?
To effectively identify your SEO competitors, utilize tools such as SEMrush, Ahrefs, and BrightLocal, along with conducting manual Google searches. These methods will reveal who ranks above you for specific keywords, allowing for strategic insights.
What are some common SEO pitfalls to avoid?
To enhance your SEO efforts, avoid outdated tactics such as keyword stuffing, neglecting mobile optimization, omitting schema markup, and creating a poor user experience. Steering clear of these pitfalls will not only boost your search engine rankings but also improve user satisfaction.
How often should I conduct a competitive analysis?
Conducting a competitive analysis should be a regular practice rather than a one-off task, as frequent updates help maintain the effectiveness and relevance of your SEO strategy in a dynamic digital environment.
